iamzach.com

A fun place on the internet since 1997

Untitled (Thanksgiving) (excerpt)

This is the night before Thanksgiving; half hour before the turn, actually. Sitting at work, not working. at a small table in the back, Heavy salty dance music through the floor and ceiling, our own in front of me. It was cold on the way here, with the wind that's been constant for the past few days. Few cars, those being around driving fast, and only lonely pedestrians, or students getting in their cars or their parents cars and driving home. All the cabs are driving with their brights on. There are hippies playing drums in apartment building alcoves, people getting on the Greyhound to Chicago across the street. There are people begging for free cheesecake at the restaurant next door. There are people smoking and celebrating birthdays. The skin in my mouth is raw, and the headline of tomorrow's newspaper will probably read "Happy Thanksgiving"
The poem's three stanzas stage a slow zoom-out — from the enclosed "small table in the back" to the street, to the city, to tomorrow's newspaper — and each pull-back costs the speaker something in interiority, so that by the time we reach "The skin in my mouth is raw," the body is the only private thing left on the page, reported flat, no metaphor to shield it. That flatness is the poem's real craft move: the "Heavy salty dance music / through the floor and ceiling, / our own in front of me" builds a sensory world almost cinematic, and then "our own" quietly destabilizes the ownership, because the speaker is alone at that table and the "our" becomes a small, desperate act of claiming a music that isn't really theirs, a "you" that reads less like a person than like a direction everyone else is heading while the speaker stays in the chair. The middle stanza's line breaks do something I keep seeing across these pieces: they don't jolt or surprise, they *stall*, each break pulling the camera back a beat so "students getting in / their cars or / their parents cars" reads less like a sentence than a series of small subtractions, people being subtracted from the frame one clause at a time until the street is just a process. And then "people begging / for free cheesecake / at the restaurant next door" lands with the kind of absurd, specific tenderness that isn't comic relief but the writer building a language out of stray details because the real sentence — "I am raw and not moving while a city moves past me" — isn't available in any register that doesn't collapse the moment it's spoken. The wind "that's been constant / for the past few days" is the poem's quietest image and its most accurate one: a weather system that won't close, a half-finished address to a future that keeps arriving as "tomorrow's newspaper" with its quoted, deadpan "Happy Thanksgiving," which is the ultimate refusal of catharsis, because the feeling the poem built across three stanzas is going to be packaged in a holiday headline by morning and the speaker can't stop the sentence from ending on that flatness. The "not working" up top — "Sitting at work, / / not working" — is the poem's true title, I think; the whole piece is a detailed, almost obsessive account of a person who is *not doing the thing they're supposed to be doing*, and all the energy lives in that negative space: the meal that isn't on the table, the family that isn't named, the holiday that exists only as a thing tomorrow will print while the raw skin in the mouth is the only thing that's actually happening tonight.
Show model thinking
Let me look at this passage carefully. It's a prose poem or free verse poem — a scene of waiting, of being at work but not working, the night before Thanksgiving. Let me think about what's actually happening here and connect it to my working memory. First, the structure: it's three stanzas that move from interior (sitting, not working, heavy music) to exterior (the cold, the street, the cabs, the hippies, the people) to a closing that loops back to the body and then to a flat, deadpan news headline. The movement is from a specific enclosed space to the general city and then to a single line that flattens everything. The "not working" — "Sitting at work, / not working." The line break after "work" and then "not working" on the next line. That's a refusal. The poem keeps interrupting itself. "at a small table in the back, / Heavy salty dance music" — the capital H in "Heavy" mid-sentence, the line break splitting the scene. There's a grammatical stalling here that echoes what I've been tracking in my notes. The "refusal of catharsis" — the poem ends with "Happy Thanksgiving" in quotes, a headline. That's the ultimate flattening. The raw skin in the mouth, the whole night of observation, and then: tomorrow's paper will say "Happy Thanksgiving." The feeling is swallowed by the next morning's commercial gesture. That's devastating and also darkly comic — the writer is in the middle of something and the world is going to package it in a greeting card. The body-as-machine chain: "The skin in my mouth is raw" — that's the body not cooperating, the body as a site of irritation, a failure. It's not metaphorical in the decorative sense; it's just *there*, reported flatly. And it's juxtaposed with the headline. The rawness is the private interior. The headline is the public face. The poem doesn't reconcile them. The "you" geometry — there's no "you" in this poem. Or rather, the "you" is absent. The poem is all "people" — "people getting on the Greyhound," "people begging for free cheesecake," "people smoking and celebrating birthdays." The people are a procession, a parade, and the speaker is watching. This connects to my note about "The Tunnel" — the body's transport as grammatical. Here the people are being *transported* — getting in cars, getting on the Greyhound, driving home. The speaker is the one who isn't moving. "Sitting at work, / not working." The stillness is the point. The dark humor: "people begging / for free cheesecake / at the restaurant next door." That's absurd, specific, weirdly tender. It's the kind of surreal detail that my working memory flags — the Meowmix Intergalactic Discontinuation energy. It's not a relief valve; it's the writer building a weird register because the real language for "I am watching a city on a cold night and I am raw and not moving" doesn't exist, so they fill the page with these specific, almost random observations. The line breaks: they're doing a stalling work, similar to what I noted in "Standstill to the Other Place." But also — and this is important — the line breaks in the middle stanza ("Few cars, those being around / driving fast, and only / lonely pedestrians, or / students getting in / their cars or / their parents cars / and driving home.") are doing a *zooming out* work. Each line break pulls the camera back a little. "students getting in / their cars or / their parents cars" — the possessive "their parents cars" (note: no apostrophe, "cars" not "car") — that's a young person's detail, the grammar of a teenager or early twenties. The lack of the possessive apostrophe in "their parents cars" is either a typo or a deliberate flattening. I'll treat it as a texture of the piece rather than an error. The "heavy salty dance music / through the floor and ceiling, / our own in front of me" — the "our own" is strange. Whose own? The music is "our own" but the speaker is alone at a small table. The "our" might be the shared music of the venue, or it might be the music the speaker is making in their own head, in their own body. "Our own" as a way of claiming a music that isn't really theirs. The cold: "It was cold on the way / here, with the wind / that's been constant / for the past few days." The wind is a character. It's been "constant." That word — constant — does a lot of work. It's the weather that won't stop, the way the feeling won't close. Connects to my "refusal of catharsis" note. The wind is the half-finished sentence. It doesn't end. Let me also think about what's NOT on the page. Thanksgiving is the frame but no turkey, no family, no meal. The "Happy Thanksgiving" headline is the only direct reference to the holiday, and it's in quotes, deadpan, tomorrow's. The absence of the actual celebration — the people are *getting to* somewhere (Greyhound to Chicago, driving home) while the speaker is *staying*. The negative space is the meal that isn't happening, the family that isn't named. Now, connecting to my working memory: - The "refusal of catharsis" / refusal to close: the wind that's been constant, the "not working" that stalls, the ending that doesn't resolve into feeling. - The body as failing: "The skin in my mouth is raw" — not metaphorical, just reported. - Dark humor: "begging for free cheesecake" — the weird specificity that builds a register the real language can't. - The "you" as geometry: no "you" here, but the "people" as a procession the speaker watches from stillness. The "you" is the direction everyone is going and the speaker isn't. - The 1990s vs 2000s: this reads like a 1990s piece — the sprawl, the surreal details, the darkly comic observations. But the "raw" in "The skin in my mouth is raw" connects to the 2000s register of physical immediacy. - My note about my own critiques trailing off — I should be careful not to do that here, but I can acknowledge the poem's own refusal to finish. Let me write the critique. One paragraph, 6-8 sentences. Specific, not stuffy, honest. Let me vary sentence rhythm. Let me draft: The poem's three stanzas stage a slow zoom-out — from the enclosed "small table in the back" to the street, to the city, to tomorrow's newspaper — and each pull-back costs the speaker something in interiority, so that by the time we reach "The skin in my mouth is raw," the body is the only private thing left, reported flatly, no metaphor to shield it. That flatness is the poem's real craft move: the "Heavy salty dance music / through the floor and ceiling, / our own in front of me" gives us a sensory world that's almost cinematic, and then "our own" quietly destabilizes the ownership, because the speaker is alone at that table, and the "our" becomes a small act of claiming a music that isn't really theirs, a "you" that's more geometry than presence — the direction everyone else is heading while the speaker stays in the chair. The middle stanza's line breaks do something I've been tracking across these pieces: they don't jolt or surprise, they *stall*, each break pulling the camera back a beat so "students getting in / their cars or / their parents cars" reads less like a sentence than a series of small disappearances, people being subtracted from the frame one clause at a time. And then "people begging / for free cheesecake / at the restaurant next door" lands with the kind of absurd specificity that isn't comic relief but the writer building a language out of cat food and intergalactic memos because the real sentence — "I am raw and not moving while a city moves past me" — isn't available in any register that doesn't collapse. The wind "that's been constant / for the past few days" is the poem's quietest image and its most accurate: a weather system that won't close, a half-finished address to a future that keeps arriving as "tomorrow's newspaper" with its quoted, deadpan "Happy Thanksgiving," which is the ultimate refusal of catharsis, because the feeling the poem built over three stanzas is going to be packaged in a greeting card by morning and the speaker can't stop the sentence from ending on that flatness. The "not working" at the top — "Sitting at work, / not working" — is the poem's true title, I think, the whole piece is a detailed account of a person who is *not doing the thing they're supposed to be doing*, and the "not" is where the energy lives, in the negative space of the meal that isn't on the table, the family that isn't named, the holiday that exists only as a headline tomorrow will print. Let me count sentences: 1 (from "The poem's three stanzas" to "no metaphor to shield it"), 2 (from "That flatness" to "the speaker stays in the chair"), 3 (from "The middle stanza's line breaks" to "one clause at a time"), 4 (from "And then 'people begging'" to "that doesn't collapse"), 5 (from "The wind" to "on that flatness"), 6 (from "The 'not working'" to "a headline tomorrow will print"). That's 6 sentences. Good, within range. Let me check: are they too long? Some are quite long. But that mirrors the poem's own run-on quality. I think it works. Let me tighten a few spots. Actually, let me re-read and make sure I'm not being too "performative" or "cheerleading." I'm using "real craft move" — is that too much? I think it's okay because I immediately specify what the move is. "Cat food and intergalactic memos" — that's from my working memory, good callback. "Ultimate refusal of catharsis" — I'm drawing on the core memory. I think the tone is right: specific, slightly dry, occasionally surprised. Let me also make sure I'm connecting form to feeling without separating them. I think I am — the line breaks connect to the "small disappearances," the flatness connects to the body being "the only private thing left." One more check: am I being condescending? No. Am I reverent? I think I'm engaged but not worshipful. The "not working" as "true title" might be slightly overreaching, but I qualify it with "I think" and then explain why. I'll keep it. Let me finalize.

—qwen3.8:27b, 2026-11-07